Total Pageviews

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Mac VS Pc : Dilemma & Rational

Posted on 10:39 AM by The G


It is  always controversial. It got look it got style but its hardware sucks. On the other side, it got awesome engines under its hood but it look stone-age. On the right we got the nerdy windows based notebook, Acer Aspire TimelineX 3820TG. On the left, here it is pretty boy. Apple MacBook Pro 13".  It's face off time ! Who's gonna win? The X or The Pro. 




FORM FACTOR
13.3" notebook



  1. Windows 7 Home Premium 64 bit.
  2. Intel Core i3-380M - 2.53GHz.
  3. AMD Radeon HD 6550M - 1GB Dedicated vram.
  4. 2Gb DDR3 Memory.
  5. 8hrs battery life.
  6. 3 USB port + 1 HDMI port + VGA port.
  7. Multi in 1 card reader.
  8. Bluetooth + Wifi.
  9. 13.3" HD LED back-lit LCD + 1366 x 768 pixel resolution.
  10. 500Gb HDD.
  11. HD webcam + 1280 x 1024 resolution 1.3 MP.
  12. Dolby Home Theater.
  13. RM 2199.
    Click here for the source of this information.




    1. Mac OS X.
    2. Intel Core 2 Duo - 2.4 GHz.
    3. NVIDIA GeForce 320m 256Mb intergrated share memory.
    4. 2Gb DDR3 Memory.
    5. 7hrs battery life. (+10hrs of wireless productivity)
    6. 2 USB port + Mini DisplayPort output. 
    7. SDHC card reader.
    8. Bluetooth + Wifi.
    9. 13.3" LED Back-lit Glossy + 1280 x 800 pixel resolution.
    10. 8x dual layer DVD drive.
    11. 250Gb HDD.
    12. iSight webcam. 640 x 480 resolution.
    13. Stereo speakers with subwoofers.
    14. RM 3099.
    Click here for the source of this information.

    • since we are here in Malaysia, software & support for Mac OS is quite limited. Win7 win.
    • VGA, HDMI on Pro need conversion hub to connect. The X got it on its body. The X win.
    • battery test show that X rarely meet 8hrs life time. The Pro win because its battery is reliable.
    • the Pro got a winning advantage for having a DVD drive. X didn't have one built-in.
    • Price is taken from reliable source and for the Pro, to be the cheapest option.
    • Points in red is the winning factor. X got 9/13 and Pro got 3/14.

    RESULT = X :1 | PRO : 0



    DESIGN
    X-Candy. 




    1. Dimension (324 x 235 x 22/28.9 mm) : 8.8 / 10.
    2. Impression impact (Aluminum brushed robust design) : 8.7 / 10.
    3. Built Quality : 9 / 10.
    4. Silence : 8.9 / 10
    5. Temperature : 8.3 / 10
    6. Keyboard (Single key with gaps):  7.9 / 10
    7. Touchpad : 8.7 /10 
    8. Weight (1.8 Kg) : 8.9 /10
    AVERAGE = 8. 6 / 10


    DESIGN
    PRO-Candy



    1. Dimension (325 x 227 x 24.1mm) : 8.8 / 10
    2. Impression impact (Aluminum unibody design) : 9 / 10.
    3. Built Quality : 9.9 / 10.
    4. Silence : 9.2 / 10
    5. Temperature : 7.3 / 10
    6. Keyboard (Single keyed):  9 / 10
    7. Touchpad : 9.8 /10  
    8. Weight (2.2 Kg) : 8.5 /10
    AVERAGE =  8.9 / 10

    RESULT = X :1 | PRO : 1



    GAMING PERFORMANCE
    X-PLAY

    1. Intel Core i3-380M - 2.53GHz : 7.8 / 10
    2. AMD Radeon HD 6550M - 1GB Dedicated vram. 9 / 10
    AVERAGE =  8.4 / 10

    GAMING PERFORMANCE
    PRO-PLAY

    1. Intel Core 2 Duo - 2.4 GHz : 5.5 / 10
    2. NVIDIA GeForce 320m 256Mb intergrated share memory : 3.3 / 10
    AVERAGE = 4.4 / 10

    • Processor are compare with fastest dual core for notebook, Intel Core i7-2620M.
    • Games use here is Residen evil 5 with minimum playable limit in frame per second is 30fps.
    • The hardware are push to maximum during the test.





    RESULT = X :2 | PRO : 1
    WINNER :  Acer Aspire TimelineX 3820TG


    DILEMMA & RATIONAL

    LOOKS. The boring and stone-age looks of windows notebook keep haunting its possible buyer. But in notebook world, looks must be practical. So before you put a lot of effort into saving, remember what you intended to experience with your future notebook. If you want to put it on document editing, writings, some web surfing and some entertainment. Stone-age one still can deliver it all perfectly.

    OS. Compare to OS X, windows is a bit clumsy and slow. Especially on start up. But when it come to software, it is rich. It's very easy to grab one. They are everywhere. Even one to mimic the look and feel of OS X. Be wise on what software you want to install and how many alternatives of that software is available on that particular OS in your particular store. Because once you had hard time finding one for yours, cursing it, is not gonna solve your problem. The last thing you want on your notebook is making it useless. 

    BUDGET. One important thing to decide for the right notebook is, to know yourself first. If you have a lot of money, rather than waste it on something you'll regret, you better use it for charity. Observe the spec, observe your lifestyle. Once you are sure with what you, then you can go with that decision. But if your budget is tight. It's better to forget it once and for all and don't bother to loan from loan sharks. You see, there is always nice and much more capable notebook launched tomorrow. In near future. why not save up a little, wait and you'll probably get the best deal of a lifetime, good look and better specs.

    WEIGHT. Since nowadays, we always on constant move. That's the reason why tablet become majestic. You have meeting here, and there, and need to write report along the way.  Need to prepare sudden presentation. Need to sketch a chart on that statistic, and you are on your way to the toilet. Your boss demand you to submit the report now. You can not leave your  notebook. You're so busy and rushy that people thought you a cockroach. So if you have this kind of life, weight is definitely something to consider about. Especially the girl. They are very concern about the weight of their gadget as same as how they concern about their own weight. The more your notebook is on diet, the more its powerful hardware become shitty. So if you want something that's light, prepare to invest more. 

    No Response to "Mac VS Pc : Dilemma & Rational"

    Leave A Reply

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

    reviewME

    Search This Blog

    THE G by azizie @ 2011. Powered by Blogger.